In the ongoing human search for tools that extend our self-knowledge, Xiaomi's Watch S1 Pro presents a cautionary parable: the gap between aspiration and execution, dressed in sapphire glass and stainless steel. Tested over weeks by Wareable in early 2023, the watch promises flagship status but delivers inconsistent fitness data, hollow smartwatch features, and a design that borrows without distinguishing itself. It is a reminder that premium pricing is a claim, not a guarantee — and that the most important specification a health device can carry is trustworthiness.
Xiaomi Watch S1 Pro fails to justify premium price despite solid battery life
Battery life cannot compensate for inaccurate tracking
Mark
Why does a watch with dual-frequency GPS still miss distances by half a mile?
Mimi
That's the question. The hardware is there—it can talk to five different satellite systems. But implementation matters more than specs. The tracking worm shows it; the watch places you on a field when you're on pavement. It's a software or calibration problem Xiaomi hasn't solved.
Mark
If the battery lasts two weeks, doesn't that alone make it worth considering?
Mimi
Only if you don't care what the watch is actually measuring. Battery life is table stakes now. It's not a differentiator; it's the minimum. When your heart rate data is wrong by 24 BPM, the fact that you can go eight days without charging doesn't matter.
Mark
The design looks classic in the photos. What's wrong with it in person?
Mimi
It looks like a Fossil from 2015. There's nothing wrong with classic, but there's a difference between timeless and dated. And the leather band—it feels cheap. The whole thing whispers that Xiaomi is still learning how to build a premium watch.
Mark
You mentioned most health features are turned off by default. Why would they do that?
Mimi
Probably battery. But it's also a sign of incomplete thinking. If these features matter enough to include, they should matter enough to turn on. Instead, you have to hunt through settings to get basics like sleep tracking. It feels like an afterthought.
Mark
So what's the actual use case for this watch?
Mimi
Someone who wants two weeks of battery and doesn't mind that their fitness data is occasionally nonsense. Someone who doesn't need apps or cellular. Honestly, that's a small audience at this price point.
El Pulso
- Heart rate readings during real workouts drifted as far as 24 BPM from actual averages, turning fitness data into unreliable noise rather than actionable insight.
- GPS tracking failed on half of test runs, placing routes on nearby fields rather than actual pavement — a fundamental flaw for a device marketed to runners.
- Despite its price, the watch offers no third-party apps, no cellular connectivity, and buggy payment support, leaving it functionally closer to a basic fitness band than a true smartwatch.
- Health sensors for sleep, blood oxygen, and skin temperature exist but sit disconnected from any meaningful analysis, generating data without generating understanding.
- Battery life of eight to fourteen days is the one genuine strength, though it cannot compensate for the accuracy and feature failures surrounding it.
- At its price point, the S1 Pro competes against devices from Garmin, Samsung, and Google that outperform it in the areas that matter most, leaving little reason to choose it.
In the ongoing human search for tools that extend our self-knowledge, Xiaomi's Watch S1 Pro presents a cautionary parable: the gap between aspiration and execution, dressed in sapphire glass and stainless steel. Tested over weeks by Wareable in early 2023, the watch promises flagship status but delivers inconsistent fitness data, hollow smartwatch features, and a design that borrows without distinguishing itself. It is a reminder that premium pricing is a claim, not a guarantee — and that the most important specification a health device can carry is trustworthiness.
Xiaomi's Watch S1 Pro arrives wearing the credentials of a premium smartwatch — sapphire glass, a digital crown, a bright AMOLED display with slimmer bezels than its predecessor. In still images, it looks the part. In practice, it reads as generic, reminiscent of older Fossil designs rather than the distinctive identities Samsung, Apple, and Google have each established. The thin leather band and formal-but-hollow aesthetic hint at the deeper problem: this is a fitness tracker dressed up for a role it cannot fully play.
The smartwatch ambitions collapse quickly under scrutiny. There are no third-party apps, Alexa support is limited to on-screen text, Xiaomi Pay proved too buggy to use, and notification support skews heavily toward China-only services. Without cellular connectivity, the watch offers little that a much cheaper device couldn't provide. The software is polished and watch faces are plentiful, but these are surface comforts around a functionally limited core.
Fitness tracking — the S1 Pro's supposed strength — proves the deepest disappointment. During a recovery run, the heart rate monitor locked onto an inflated reading and held it, reporting a session average of 170 BPM against an actual 146 BPM. Strength training sessions showed similar failures. GPS accuracy was equally inconsistent: two runs tracked cleanly against a Garmin Forerunner 265, while two others fell nearly half a mile short, with the route mapped onto adjacent fields rather than actual pavement. These are not minor variances — they are the kind of errors that make the data untrustworthy.
Health features including sleep tracking, blood oxygen, stress monitoring, and skin temperature are present but feel purposeless. Most are disabled by default. Once activated, readings are broadly plausible, but there is no trend analysis, no daily guidance, no integration with the rest of your health picture. The data accumulates without meaning.
Battery life stands as the one unambiguous success. Real-world testing with GPS and health features enabled returned eight days — short of the claimed fourteen, but still competitive. Fast charging recovers roughly 40 percent in twenty minutes. It is a genuine strength, but not one that justifies the price when tracking accuracy is unreliable and smartwatch functionality is thin. The S1 Pro asks for flagship investment and returns mid-range results.
Xiaomi's latest flagship smartwatch arrives with the kind of premium positioning that demands justification—a larger display, a new digital crown, sapphire glass protection. After weeks of testing, the Watch S1 Pro does deliver on one promise: it will last roughly two weeks on a charge. Everything else feels like a compromise dressed up in stainless steel.
The watch itself is handsome enough in still photographs. The 1.47-inch AMOLED screen is bright and responsive, the reduced bezel makes it feel more display-forward than its standard S1 predecessor, and that new digital crown actually works well for navigating menus. But in person, the design reads as generic—reminiscent of Fossil's older smartwatches, lacking the distinctive visual signature that Samsung, Apple, and Google have each carved out. The leather band feels thin. The overall package suggests a fitness tracker dressed in formal wear, which becomes a problem when you realize that's essentially what it is.
Xiaomi positioned the S1 Pro as a smartwatch, but it functions more like a very expensive fitness tracker. There are no third-party apps. Alexa support amounts to screen read-outs only. Xiaomi Pay proved buggy enough to abandon during setup. Notifications exist, but third-party support is limited mostly to China-only applications. Without cellular connectivity, the watch offers little beyond what you'd find on a device costing a fraction of the price. The software is smooth and the watch faces are plentiful, but these are cosmetic comforts around a hollow core.
The real disappointment lies in what should be the S1 Pro's strength: fitness tracking. The specs suggest promise—dual-frequency GPS, heart rate monitoring, a new skin temperature sensor. In practice, accuracy is inconsistent and sometimes alarming. During a recovery run, the heart rate monitor locked onto an elevated reading and refused to update, inflating the session average to 170 BPM when the actual average was 146 BPM. A strength training session showed similar dysfunction, with the monitor failing to track elevated heart rates properly. These aren't minor fluctuations; they're the kind of errors that render the data unreliable.
GPS performance tells a similar story. Two test runs tracked accurately against a Garmin Forerunner 265. Two others came up nearly half a mile short. The tracking map itself reveals the problem: while the Garmin pinpoints exact pavement location, the S1 Pro places the route on nearby fields, sometimes significantly off the actual path. This mirrors the performance of the standard S1 from last year, suggesting Xiaomi hasn't solved the underlying issue.
Health tracking features—blood oxygen, sleep stages, stress monitoring, skin temperature—are technically present but feel disconnected from any actionable insight. Most are disabled by default, requiring a trip into the Mi Fitness app just to activate basic sleep tracking. Once enabled, readings align reasonably with devices like Whoop and Oura, but there's no integration, no daily recommendations, no trend analysis. A poor night's sleep sits isolated from the rest of your data. Skin temperature readings accumulate with no clear purpose. Sleep stages lack the granularity of competing platforms, sometimes failing to distinguish between deep and REM sleep at all. The data exists; the meaning does not.
Battery life is the one area where Xiaomi delivers without equivocation. The company promises 14 days, and with features turned off and the always-on display disabled, you can approach that figure. In real-world testing with frequent GPS-tracked runs and all health features enabled, the S1 Pro lasted eight days—still respectable, and charging is fast enough that a 20-minute session recovers roughly 40 percent. But solid battery life cannot compensate for a device that tracks your workouts inaccurately, offers minimal smartwatch functionality, and costs more than watches that do both substantially better. The S1 Pro arrives as a premium product with budget-tier execution, a watch that asks you to pay flagship prices for mid-range performance.
Citas Notables
Despite premium positioning, the watch lacks true smartwatch capabilities like third-party apps, cellular connectivity, and meaningful health insights integration.— Review findings
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en Wareable ↗
Business