In the long reckoning that follows acts of mass violence, societies must decide not only how justice is carried out, but how it is witnessed. Vice President JD Vance, speaking in Ohio on Friday, cast doubt on the Pentagon's plan to livestream the December firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan — the man who killed 13 soldiers and wounded more than 30 others in 2009 — saying he would not watch even if the broadcast proceeds. His hesitation, measured against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's public announcement of the livestream, reveals a quiet fracture within the administration
Vance doubts Pentagon will livestream Fort Hood shooter's execution, says he won't watch
Nidal Hasan killed 13 people and wounded more than 30 others in the 2009 Fort Hood attack.
I'm not going to be watching it.
Mark
So Vance is saying the Pentagon won't actually livestream this, or just that he personally won't watch?
Mimi
He's doing both—casting doubt on whether it'll happen at all, and separately saying he won't tune in if it does. Those are two different moves.
Luke
Right, but we should be careful here. Vance says "I don't know that that's actually going to happen," but Hegseth already announced it. So is Vance predicting it won't happen, or just expressing uncertainty?
Mimi
That's the reporting gap. Vance is skeptical, but the source material doesn't tell us whether he has inside information or is just expressing doubt like any observer might.
Mark
Why does Vance's faith matter to the question?
Mimi
The reporter asked him directly how livestreaming an execution fits with being Catholic. It's a legitimate question about conscience and method, not just the sentence itself.
Luke
But Vance doesn't really answer that. He pivots to the crime instead—which is a political move, not a theological one.
Mark
And Trump hasn't weighed in on the livestream part?
Mimi
Correct. He's said Hasan deserves firing squad execution, but he's silent on whether it should be broadcast.
Luke
Which means we don't actually know if the livestream will happen. Hegseth announced it, Vance doubts it, Trump approves the method but not the broadcast plan. That's three different positions.
Mark
So this is still in flux.
Mimi
Entirely. The execution date is set for December, but the format—whether it's public, whether it's livestreamed—appears to be unsettled.
Le Pouls
- Defense Secretary Hegseth's announcement that Hasan's execution would be publicly livestreamed landed like a provocation, drawing immediate criticism from Republican lawmakers and raising uncomfortable questions about the ethics of broadcasting a death.
- Vance's open skepticism — rare for a sitting vice president to voice about his own administration's plans — signals that the internal debate is far from settled.
- The case carries enormous symbolic weight for the military community, and the method of its resolution risks either honoring or reopening wounds that have never fully healed.
- President Trump has endorsed the firing squad sentence but has stayed conspicuously silent on the livestream controversy, leaving a visible gap in the administration's unified front.
- With the execution scheduled for December, the window for resolving this internal split is narrowing, and the final shape of how — and whether — the public will watch remains genuinely uncertain.
In the long reckoning that follows acts of mass violence, societies must decide not only how justice is carried out, but how it is witnessed. Vice President JD Vance, speaking in Ohio on Friday, cast doubt on the Pentagon's plan to livestream the December firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan — the man who killed 13 soldiers and wounded more than 30 others in 2009 — saying he would not watch even if the broadcast proceeds. His hesitation, measured against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's public announcement of the livestream, reveals a quiet fracture within the administration over whether the spectacle of justice serves the memory of those lost, or diminishes it.
Vice President JD Vance expressed open doubt Friday that the Pentagon will follow through on its plan to livestream the execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan, telling reporters in Ohio that he personally would not watch even if the broadcast proceeds.
The controversy was sparked a day earlier when Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that Hasan's death by firing squad, scheduled for December, would be made public and available to stream online. The declaration drew swift criticism, including from Republican members of Congress, and raised pointed questions about the appropriateness of broadcasting such an event in a case that remains deeply painful for the military community.
When pressed on how the plan squared with his Catholic faith, Vance sidestepped the direct question but did not shy from the weight of Hasan's crimes. He described the 2009 attack — in which Hasan, an Army psychiatrist, opened fire on soldiers at Fort Hood, Texas — as the worst terrorist attack on American soil outside of September 11th, noting that Hasan had murdered people at their most vulnerable, patients under his care. Thirteen were killed; more than thirty were wounded.
Still, Vance's reservations about the livestream were unmistakable. "I don't know that that's actually going to happen," he said, while urging that the focus remain on the gravity of Hasan's crimes rather than the method of execution. "If it's ultimately livestreamed, I'm not going to be watching it."
President Trump has voiced clear support for the firing squad sentence itself — telling guests at a White House Columbus Day event that Hasan "deserves" it — but has not publicly addressed the livestream question. That silence, combined with Vance's skepticism and congressional pushback, leaves the administration visibly divided over how one of the military's most symbolically charged cases will ultimately be carried out.
Vice President JD Vance expressed skepticism Friday about whether the Pentagon will actually proceed with livestreaming the execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan, scheduled for December. Speaking to reporters during a trip to Ohio, Vance said flatly that even if the plan moves forward, he will not watch.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced Thursday that Hasan's death by firing squad would be made public and available to stream—a declaration that immediately drew criticism, including from Republican members of Congress. The announcement raised questions about the appropriateness of broadcasting an execution, particularly one involving a high-profile case that remains deeply painful for the military community.
When asked how the livestream plan aligns with his Catholic faith, Vance acknowledged the gravity of Hasan's crimes without directly answering the question. Hasan, a psychiatrist, carried out what Vance called "the worst terrorist attack on American soil outside of 9/11" when he opened fire at Fort Hood in Texas in 2009. Thirteen soldiers were killed and more than thirty others were wounded in the attack. Vance emphasized that Hasan murdered people "at their most vulnerable"—soldiers he was supposed to be treating as a medical professional.
Yet Vance's skepticism about the livestream itself was unmistakable. "I don't know that that's actually going to happen," he said of the Pentagon's plan. He framed his position carefully, saying that whatever controversy surrounds the method of execution, the focus should remain on the severity of Hasan's crimes. "I hope that people don't forget that this is a guy who brutally murdered a lot of innocent people," Vance said. But he added: "If it's ultimately livestreamed, I'm not going to be watching it."
President Trump has not publicly addressed the livestream aspect of the execution, though he has made clear his support for the firing squad method itself. At a White House Columbus Day event, Trump told guests that Hasan "deserves" execution by firing squad. That approval of the underlying sentence, however, does not necessarily extend to the Pentagon's plan to broadcast it, leaving the final shape of the execution still uncertain. The announcement by Hegseth has created a visible split between administration officials on how to handle a case that remains symbolically significant to the military and the nation.
Citations marquantes
I don't know that that's actually going to happen.— Vice President JD Vance, on the Pentagon's livestream plan
Death penalty through firing squad, and he deserves it.— President Trump, at a White House Columbus Day event
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur CBS News ↗
Politics & Governance