For decades, a rule requiring employers to prove no qualified American worker exists before sponsoring foreign talent for permanent residency sat dormant on the books — unenforced, uncontested, largely forgotten. This week, the Trump administration activated that rule, suspending Microsoft, Adobe, Cognizant, Infosys, and others from sponsoring H-1B holders for green cards, with Vice President Vance framing the move as a defense of American workers against deliberate displacement. The action arrives freighted with irony: hours later, President Trump honored Microsoft's CEO — himself a former H-
Trump Admin Suspends Microsoft From H-1B Green Card Sponsorship Program
Once you have a green card, you're no longer dependent on your employer
Mark
So the administration is saying Microsoft used H-1B visas to replace American workers. What's actually happening here?
Mimi
Vance is conflating two different things. H-1B visas are temporary—three to six years, and the worker is tied to that employer. Green cards are permanent residency. Once you have one, you're independent of your employer. The suspension blocks Microsoft from sponsoring H-1B holders for green cards, which is the pathway to that independence.
Luke
But the numbers Vance cited—6,000 layoffs, 6,300 H-1B visas, 3,000 green cards—those are real. Does Microsoft's response actually address whether they're using the system to undercut wages?
Mimi
Microsoft says 80 percent of its H-1B filings were for existing employees, not new arrivals. And they claim they pay H-1B workers the same as Americans doing the same work.
Luke
That's Microsoft's claim. The wage data is genuinely contradictory. One study shows H-1B workers earning more; another shows them earning 16 percent less. We don't actually know which is true for Microsoft specifically.
Mark
What makes this suspension significant if the rule has always existed?
Mimi
It's never been enforced. A professor at Howard University told the Seattle Times that these requirements—proving you can't find American workers—have been on the books but never actually policed. This is the first time.
Luke
Which means we're in uncharted territory. We don't know how this gets applied, whether it holds up legally, or what the actual impact will be on the companies or the workers already in the pipeline.
Mark
And the irony with Nadella getting a medal the same day?
Mimi
Nadella is a former H-1B holder himself. Trump honored him hours before suspending the program that brought him here.
Luke
Though to be fair, Nadella is now a permanent resident and a CEO. He's not competing for entry-level positions. The policy and the honor aren't necessarily contradictory—they're just awkwardly timed.
Il Polso
- VP Vance accused Microsoft of deliberately burying job ads in low-circulation newspapers to manufacture the appearance that no American workers applied — a scheme he claims justified importing what he called 'foreign indentured servants' while laying off 10,000 domestic employees.
- The accusation rests on a critical misreading: green cards do the opposite of binding workers to employers — once issued, they grant full labor market freedom, allowing holders to change jobs, negotiate wages, and move without fear of deportation.
- Microsoft pushed back with data, stating 80 percent of its H-1B filings last year were extensions for existing employees, and that H-1B workers receive pay comparable to American colleagues in equivalent roles.
- Wage research remains contested — one analysis shows H-1B holders earning more than U.S. citizens in similar positions, while another finds them earning roughly 16 percent less, leaving the 'cheap labor' narrative unresolved.
- The suspension transforms a theoretical rule into live enforcement for the first time in the H-1B program's history, even as the administration simultaneously celebrated immigrant tech founders at a White House honors ceremony the same afternoon.
For decades, a rule requiring employers to prove no qualified American worker exists before sponsoring foreign talent for permanent residency sat dormant on the books — unenforced, uncontested, largely forgotten. This week, the Trump administration activated that rule, suspending Microsoft, Adobe, Cognizant, Infosys, and others from sponsoring H-1B holders for green cards, with Vice President Vance framing the move as a defense of American workers against deliberate displacement. The action arrives freighted with irony: hours later, President Trump honored Microsoft's CEO — himself a former H-1B visa holder — with the National Medal of Technology and Innovation, a ceremony that also celebrated Elon Musk, Sergey Brin, Jensen Huang, and Lisa Su, all immigrants or former visa holders whose careers the very same system made possible.
On Thursday, Vice President JD Vance appeared before the Fraud Task Force to announce that Microsoft, Adobe, Cognizant, Infosys, and several other technology companies were being suspended from sponsoring H-1B visa holders for green cards. The move marks the first active enforcement of a rule that has existed for decades without ever being policed: employers must demonstrate they cannot find qualified American workers before sponsoring foreign nationals for permanent residency.
Vance's case against Microsoft was pointed. He alleged the company places job listings in small-circulation newspapers, ensuring minimal American visibility, then uses the absence of domestic applicants to justify hiring H-1B workers. He noted Microsoft laid off roughly 10,000 employees last year while obtaining thousands of H-1B visas and nearly 3,000 green cards, framing the workers as 'foreign indentured servants' displacing Americans at scale.
But the characterization contains a significant flaw. H-1B visas do tie workers to their sponsoring employer — but green cards, the very documents at the center of this suspension, dissolve that dependency entirely. A green card holder can change employers, negotiate freely, and work anywhere in the country without immigration consequences, possessing the same labor market rights as any U.S. citizen. As one former immigration official put it, the green card is precisely what frees a worker from employer control.
Microsoft, which leads the nation in PERM applications — the green card sponsorship pathway — responded by noting that 80 percent of its recent H-1B filings were extensions for employees already working at the company, not new arrivals. The remaining cases involved individuals already legally present in the U.S., amounting to just one percent of its total American workforce. The company also stated it pays H-1B employees at rates comparable to American workers in similar roles.
Wage data tells a complicated story. Some analyses show H-1B holders earning more than U.S. citizens in equivalent positions, suggesting companies pursue specialized talent rather than discount labor. Other research finds H-1B workers earning roughly 16 percent less, representing meaningful savings over a visa term. Scholars note the suspension is historically significant precisely because the underlying rule has never before been enforced.
The day's symbolism was difficult to ignore. Hours after the suspension was announced, President Trump presented Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella — a former H-1B visa holder himself — with the National Medal of Technology and Innovation. Also honored were Elon Musk, Sergey Brin, Jensen Huang, and Lisa Su, all immigrants or former visa holders. Nadella publicly thanked the president for the recognition. The juxtaposition captured the administration's unresolved tension between restricting the immigration pathways that built Silicon Valley and celebrating the figures those pathways produced.
Vice President JD Vance stood before the Fraud Task Force on Thursday and announced that Microsoft, along with Adobe, Cognizant, Infosys, and other technology firms, could no longer sponsor H-1B visa holders for green cards. The suspension marks the first time the Trump administration has enforced a rule that has technically existed for decades but has never been actively policed: employers must demonstrate they cannot find qualified American workers before sponsoring foreign talent for permanent residency.
Vance's accusation centered on what he described as a deliberate scheme. Microsoft, he alleged, places job advertisements in small-town newspapers—outlets with minimal circulation—knowing few Americans will see them. Once the company can claim no qualified domestic applicants responded, it uses that gap to justify bringing in H-1B workers, whom Vance characterized as "foreign indentured servants." He pointed to specific numbers: Microsoft laid off roughly 10,000 workers last year while obtaining 6,300 H-1B visas and nearly 3,000 green cards. "For every worker that Microsoft laid off, they replaced that worker with one and a half foreign indentured servants," Vance said.
The logic, however, contains a fundamental mischaracterization of what the green card program actually does. H-1B visas grant temporary work status for three to six years, tying workers to their sponsoring employer. A green card—the permanent residency document at the center of this suspension—does the opposite. Once issued, it severs the employer-employee immigration relationship entirely. A green card holder can change jobs, negotiate wages, and move between employers without fear of deportation or visa cancellation. They possess the same legal rights as any U.S. citizen in the labor market. Doug Rand, who advised U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services under the Biden administration, told the Associated Press: "Once you have a green card, you're no longer dependent on your employer for your immigration status—you're a permanent resident who can change jobs and negotiate higher wages without fear."
Microsoft is indeed the nation's fifth-highest user of H-1B visas, though Amazon leads overall. But Microsoft does rank first in applications through the Permanent Labor Certification Program (PERM), the pathway through which employers sponsor current visa holders for green cards. Software development accounts for 22.7 percent of all PERM applications certified by the Labor Department—more than any other sector. When asked about the suspension, Microsoft responded with a statement noting that 80 percent of its roughly 6,000 H-1B applications in the last fiscal year were extensions or status changes for existing employees already working at the company. The remaining 20 percent, the company said, involved individuals already legally present in the United States who chose to work for Microsoft, representing just 1 percent of its total U.S. workforce. The company also stated it pays H-1B employees at the same rates as American workers in comparable roles.
The data on H-1B wages presents a murkier picture. A Newsweek analysis found that H-1B holders on the global HR platform Deel earned a median of $140,000, compared to $130,000 for U.S. citizens in similar roles—suggesting companies pursue rare talent rather than cheap labor. But other research using different datasets found H-1B workers earned roughly 16 percent less than Americans in equivalent positions, translating to nearly $100,000 in employer savings over a six-year visa term. Ron Hira, a political science professor at Howard University, told the Seattle Times that the suspension is significant precisely because the rule requiring employers to prove they cannot find American workers has "never been enforced" in the program's history.
The timing of Vance's announcement created an awkward juxtaposition. Hours after the suspension was announced, President Trump presented Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella—himself a former H-1B visa holder—with the National Medal of Technology and Innovation. Also honored that day were Elon Musk, who has said he held an H-1B visa; Google co-founder Sergey Brin; Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang; and AMD CEO Lisa Su, all immigrants or former visa holders. Nadella posted a public thank you to Trump for "this incredible honor today." The administration also announced it is investigating nine universities, including Harvard, Yale, and Stanford, regarding their handling of student exchange-visitor visas. The suspension of Microsoft and other firms from green card sponsorship represents a sharp policy reversal, one that transforms a decades-old rule from theoretical constraint into active enforcement.
Citazioni salienti
For every worker that Microsoft laid off, they replaced that worker with one and a half foreign indentured servants.— VP JD Vance
Once you have a green card, you're no longer dependent on your employer for your immigration status—you're a permanent resident who can change jobs and negotiate higher wages without fear.— Doug Rand, former Biden-era USCIS advisor
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su Gizmodo ↗
Politics & Governance