In the middle of a lacrosse season, fourteen North Jersey players are being recognized not for what they put on the scoreboard, but for what they put into the game — ground balls fought for, defensive assignments absorbed, teammates steadied. These are the athletes whose contributions live in the spaces between statistics, whose value is measured in trust earned rather than points tallied. Their coaches, watching closely from the sidelines, understand what the box score cannot say: that teams are built not only by those who score, but by those who make scoring possible.
North Jersey's Lacrosse Unsung Heroes: The Players Who Win Beyond the Box Score
He doesn't show up in the stat books but man if he slides to you, you'll know it
Why does this story matter now, in May? Aren't the awards already decided?
The awards are decided, but the season isn't over. These players are still out there winning games. The point is that we rarely stop to notice them while it's happening.
But we should ask: how many of these players actually made a measurable difference? We have stats for some—Coby Cohen's 21 goals, Kayleigh Windram's 19 caused turnovers. For others, we're mostly taking the coach's word for it.
That's fair. But that's also the whole point. A caused turnover shows up in the box score. A player who directs traffic from the crease or sets the tone at practice—that doesn't. The coaches are the ones who see it every day.
So these are the players who would be missed most if they were gone?
Exactly. Henry Cannon came back from a broken leg and immediately became useful in multiple positions. Roman Rodriguez waited three years for his chance and didn't transfer. That kind of loyalty and flexibility—that's what wins in the second half of a season.
I notice several of these players are seniors or juniors, and several are heading to college or have other plans. Is this partly a "senior night" story dressed up as something else?
Some of them are seniors, yes. But Lucy Meserole is a sophomore, Anthony Simone is a freshman. The story isn't about farewell—it's about recognizing that depth and role players drive team success, at any grade level.
What happens to a team when it loses one of these players?
You see it in the numbers. St. Joseph went from 7-13 to 8-4 when Roman Rodriguez took over in goal. West Milford became a co-champion with Evan Melucci doing the clearing work. These aren't flashy changes, but they're real.
One more thing: we should note that some of these quotes are pretty generic. "Best motor," "great effort," "sets the tone." Coaches say these things about a lot of players. What makes these 14 specifically worthy of this story?
The coaches chose them. And the reporting found specific evidence—Cannon's return from injury, Simone being a freshman starter, Windram not picking up a stick until high school. Those details matter.
So the reader should understand: this isn't a definitive list of the best role players in North Jersey. It's a snapshot of 14 players who caught their coaches' attention for doing the unglamorous work well.
El Pulso
- Coaches across North Jersey are sounding an alarm about a quiet crisis in how we measure athletic value — the stat sheet is leaving the most important players invisible.
- From a senior recovering from a broken leg to a sophomore reshaping her position mid-season, these players absorb the disruption of injury, scheme changes, and limited depth without breaking stride.
- Each athlete has found a way to navigate their role — whether mentoring a freshman sibling, organizing a charity game, or waiting three seasons for a starting spot — turning sacrifice into team identity.
- The season's second half is arriving with these unsung contributors now firmly embedded as the structural core of their programs, their absence more telling than any highlight reel.
In the middle of a lacrosse season, fourteen North Jersey players are being recognized not for what they put on the scoreboard, but for what they put into the game — ground balls fought for, defensive assignments absorbed, teammates steadied. These are the athletes whose contributions live in the spaces between statistics, whose value is measured in trust earned rather than points tallied. Their coaches, watching closely from the sidelines, understand what the box score cannot say: that teams are built not only by those who score, but by those who make scoring possible.
The box score tells you who scored. It doesn't tell you who won the game.
Across North Jersey lacrosse, coaches are pausing mid-season to name the players whose contributions rarely appear in statistics but whose absence would be immediately felt. These are athletes who fight for loose balls, direct defensive traffic, and ask for nothing beyond the chance to compete. As the season's second half begins, fourteen of them have earned something harder to quantify than goals: the deep trust of their coaches and teammates.
Henry Cannon of Ramapo spent last spring in a full cast after breaking his leg, watching from the sideline. He returned this year willing to play any role the team needed — pole, short-stick midfielder, faceoff specialist — with no scholarship on the line and no all-star ambitions. He's heading into plumbing after graduation and plays simply because he loves the game. At Tenafly, Coby Cohen has been the backbone of a young roster for four varsity seasons, posting career highs in scoring this spring while his coach credits him more for the way he raises everyone around him. Kate Glass at Pascack Hills moved from crease to two-way midfielder without missing a beat — she's also the school's salutatorian and a three-sport athlete whose work ethic sets the tone before warmups begin.
Aiden Keenan at Saddle Brook absorbed contact in the crease all season while mentoring his freshman brother, part of a team that won its first division title in program history. Nick Lamparillo at Pascack Valley used his first year as a starter to accumulate ground balls, cause turnovers, and organize a charity game that raised $900 for an anti-drug campaign. Roman Rodriguez at St. Joseph spent three seasons backing up Division I-bound goalies before finally earning his starting role — and rather than transfer, he stayed, committed to St. John Fisher, and became the voice of a defense holding opponents to fewer than seven goals per game.
Sophomore Lucy Meserole at Dwight-Englewood has already shifted positions once in response to a scheme change and contributed across multiple statistical categories. Taylor Tremblay at Mahwah didn't pick up a stick until freshman year and is now the team's defensive engine. Connor Soha, also at Mahwah, returned from a broken wrist and a concussion to become one of the team's most versatile and indispensable players. Kayleigh Windram at River Dell, a three-year starter heading to Ramapo College, anchors her defense with composure that shows up most clearly in the moments the stat sheet cannot capture.
What connects all of them is a willingness to do the work that doesn't get celebrated — and the understanding that teams built on that kind of commitment tend to reveal themselves fully only in the second half of a season, when it matters most.
The box score tells you who scored. It doesn't tell you who won the game.
In North Jersey lacrosse, there are players whose names rarely appear in the stat columns but whose absence would be felt immediately—the ones who spend a season fighting for loose balls, directing traffic from the crease, and asking nothing in return except the chance to play. As the second half of the season unfolds, these are the athletes who have earned the quiet respect of their coaches and the trust of their teammates, even if the scorebook doesn't always reflect what they've done.
Henry Cannon, a senior at Ramapo, spent last April recovering from a broken leg. Months in a full cast meant watching from the sidelines, but he returned this spring willing to play wherever the team needed him—pole, short-stick defensive midfielder, faceoff specialist. He isn't chasing a college scholarship or an all-star award. He's heading into plumbing after graduation and plays because he loves the game. Coach Stephen Harvey describes him as someone who brings full effort every single time he steps on the field, with defensive footwork and positioning that stand out even in a program full of skilled players.
At Tenafly, Coby Cohen has become the spine of a young roster. A four-year varsity player, he's the kind of senior who grinds through defensive clears and ride situations while also being the voice that holds teammates accountable. This spring he's posted career highs—21 goals and 11 assists—but coach Eric Quaranti credits him less for the scoring and more for the way he elevates everyone around him. Pascack Hills' Kate Glass took on a new challenge this year, moving from a lower crease role to two-way midfielder, a transition her coach Lindsey Walsh calls seamless because Glass simply outworks everyone else on the field. She's also the school's salutatorian and a three-sport athlete, the kind of player whose effort sets the tone before anyone else has even warmed up.
Aiden Keenan at Saddle Brook lives in the crease, absorbing contact and turning broken plays into scoring chances. His school won its first division title in program history, and Keenan spent the season mentoring younger players, including his freshman brother Sean. Nick Lamparillo at Pascack Valley made the most of his first year as a starter on defense, accumulating 20 ground balls and eight caused turnovers while also organizing the team's annual charity game—they designed purple jerseys and raised $900 for an anti-drug abuse campaign. Evan Melucci, West Milford's senior captain, is a short-stick defensive midfielder who rarely shows up in the stat book but has become the reliable bridge from defense to offense, handling the toughest matchups without complaint.
Lucy Meserole, a sophomore at Dwight-Englewood, has become one of the program's most versatile players. She started on defense as a freshman, then moved to midfield when the team switched defensive schemes, and has contributed nine goals, nine caused turnovers, and 13 draw controls. Michael Renehan at Ramsey, in his first year as a starter, has been counted on as a wing on faceoffs, a clearing option, and a ground-ball magnet in crucial moments. Roman Rodriguez at St. Joseph spent three seasons backing up Division I-bound goalies before finally getting his chance this spring. He's committed to St. John Fisher and has become the voice of the defense, directing traffic and holding opponents to just 6.58 goals per game. Coach Dan DaPonte noted that Rodriguez stayed the course when many players would have transferred, and probably would have started at most other schools in the state.
Anthony Simone, a freshman at Passaic Tech, is already one of the program's most important players—a do-it-all midfielder who handles clears, plays tight defense, and helps initiate the offense. Connor Soha at Mahwah spent last season sidelined by a broken wrist and then a concussion, but now rarely leaves the field, shifting between midfield, attack, and short-stick defensive midfielder for a team with limited depth. Taylor Tremblay, also at Mahwah, didn't pick up a stick until freshman year and has become the team's defensive engine, faceguarding top scorers and leading the team in ground balls and forced turnovers. Kayleigh Windram at River Dell, a three-year starter and senior captain heading to Ramapo College, anchors the defense with 19 caused turnovers and the kind of composure that shows up in big moments even when the stat sheet doesn't capture it.
What connects all of them is a willingness to do the work that doesn't get celebrated. They understand their roles, they execute them without complaint, and they make their teams better in ways that only become obvious when they're not on the field. The second half of the season will reveal which teams have truly built something sustainable—and it will be built on the shoulders of players like these.
Citas Notables
He is 100% effort at all times. He has some of the best defensive footwork I have seen and plays great angles.— Coach Stephen Harvey on Henry Cannon
In a world of constant transfers he stayed the course. As a sophomore and junior, he probably would've started on the vast majority of teams across the state.— Coach Dan DaPonte on Roman Rodriguez