Across more than eight decades, a single painting has carried the weight of displacement, theft, and survival — seized from one of Europe's great Jewish art dealers as Nazi forces swept through the Netherlands, and discovered at last hanging quietly in an Argentine seaside home. An Argentine court has now ordered 'Portrait of a Lady' returned to Maril von Saher, the heir of Jacques Goudstikker, after the daughter of a Nazi SS financier relinquished her claim rather than face trial. The ruling is a small but deliberate act of historical repair, a reminder that justice, however delayed, can stil
Nazi-looted painting to be returned to collector's heir after Argentine court ruling
A judge ordered the painting's return after the daughter of a Nazi official agreed to surrender her claim.
Mark
So this painting was just sitting in someone's living room in Argentina for how long?
Mimi
Decades, apparently. It was discovered by a Dutch newspaper in August 2025, which means it had been there through the entire postwar period and beyond—probably since Friedrich Kadgien brought it there after fleeing Europe.
Luke
We should note that the source doesn't actually say when Kadgien acquired it or when he brought it to Argentina. We know he died in 1978, but the exact timeline of how the painting moved from Göring's possession to Kadgien's is still a gap.
Mark
And the daughter just agreed to give it back rather than go to trial?
Mimi
Yes, but it came with conditions. She and her husband avoid criminal conviction, but they're under court supervision for two years, they have to make payments to a local hospital, and they have to report their whereabouts to authorities.
Luke
That's a negotiated settlement, not a judgment of guilt. It's important to say that clearly—she wasn't convicted, and we don't know what the evidence against her would have been or how strong the prosecution's case was.
Mark
What about the heir? Does she get the painting back intact?
Mimi
Yes, though she's agreed to let it be exhibited in Argentina first before it comes to her in Connecticut. The painting was valued at around $290,000.
Luke
One thing worth noting: the painting's attribution changed during this process. It was cataloged as a Ghislandi for decades, but Argentine experts determined it was actually a Ceruti. That doesn't change the restitution claim, but it does change what the painting is.
Mark
Are there other looted works still out there?
Mimi
Almost certainly. During the same raids, police seized two more 19th-century paintings and various prints and engravings from properties owned by Kadgien and her sister. Authorities are still investigating whether those were also looted during the war.
Luke
So this case may be just the beginning of what gets uncovered in Argentina. The country became a haven for Nazi officials after the war, and it's possible there are other collections hidden in similar ways.
The Pulse
- A Dutch newspaper's discovery of the painting in a Mar del Plata living room in August 2025 broke open a secret that had endured for nearly eighty years.
- Patricia Kadgien and her husband faced criminal charges for knowingly concealing the work while international investigators were actively searching for it.
- Rather than risk conviction, Kadgien surrendered all claims to the portrait, accepting two years of court supervision and mandatory restitution payments to a local hospital.
- Argentine police simultaneously seized two additional 19th-century paintings and various prints from properties linked to the Kadgien family, raising the possibility that more looted art remains hidden.
- The painting now moves toward Maril von Saher in Greenwich, Connecticut — though she has agreed to let it be exhibited in Argentina first, a gesture that honors the country's role in its recovery.
Across more than eight decades, a single painting has carried the weight of displacement, theft, and survival — seized from one of Europe's great Jewish art dealers as Nazi forces swept through the Netherlands, and discovered at last hanging quietly in an Argentine seaside home. An Argentine court has now ordered 'Portrait of a Lady' returned to Maril von Saher, the heir of Jacques Goudstikker, after the daughter of a Nazi SS financier relinquished her claim rather than face trial. The ruling is a small but deliberate act of historical repair, a reminder that justice, however delayed, can still find its way to a door.
An Argentine judge has ordered the return of an 18th-century portrait to the heir of Jacques Goudstikker, a Jewish art dealer whose collection of roughly 1,100 works — including paintings by Rembrandt and Vermeer — was plundered after Nazi Germany invaded the Netherlands in 1940. Goudstikker fled with his family but died in a shipwreck during the escape, and the bulk of his collection was sold under duress to Hermann Göring. The portrait, long attributed to Italian Baroque painter Giuseppe Vittore Ghislandi, was later determined by Argentine experts to be the work of Giacomo Antonio Melchiorre Ceruti, and valued at approximately $290,000.
The painting surfaced in August 2025 when a Dutch newspaper found it hanging in the Mar del Plata home of Patricia Kadgien, whose father Friedrich was a financier for the Nazi SS who handled confiscated property and foreign currency before fleeing to Argentina after the war. He died in 1978 without facing prosecution. How the portrait passed into his possession remains unknown.
Rather than stand trial, Patricia Kadgien agreed to surrender the work entirely. Judge Santiago Inchausti approved the arrangement, which carries two years of court supervision and mandatory payments to a local hospital in lieu of criminal conviction. The painting will be returned to Maril von Saher, Goudstikker's sole surviving heir, who lives in Connecticut and has spent decades pursuing the recovery of her family's art. She has consented to allow the work to be exhibited in Argentina before it is transferred to her.
The case has opened wider questions. During raids on properties linked to Kadgien and her sister, Argentine police also seized two additional 19th-century paintings and various prints. Investigators are now examining whether those works, too, carry a wartime provenance — suggesting that what was hidden in Argentina may extend well beyond a single portrait.
An Argentine judge on Friday ordered the return of an 18th-century portrait to the heir of a Jewish art dealer whose collection was systematically plundered by Nazi officials after Germany invaded the Netherlands in 1940. The painting, "Portrait of a Lady," had hung in the living room of Patricia Kadgien in the seaside resort of Mar del Plata, where it was discovered by a Dutch newspaper in August 2025. Kadgien's father, Friedrich Kadgien, was a financier for the Nazi SS and one of several high-ranking German officials who escaped to Argentina after the war ended.
Jacques Goudstikker was among Europe's most prominent art dealers before the war, his collection spanning roughly 1,100 works that included paintings by Rembrandt and Vermeer. When German forces swept into the Netherlands in May 1940, Goudstikker attempted to flee with his family but died in a shipwreck during the escape. The vast majority of his collection was sold under duress to Hermann Göring, Hitler's closest associate, who used the war years to accumulate one of history's largest private art hoards. The portrait itself had been attributed for decades to the Italian Baroque painter Giuseppe Vittore Ghislandi, appearing under that name in Goudstikker's records and in exhibitions held in Amsterdam before the occupation. A court-ordered examination by Argentina's National Academy of Fine Arts later determined the work was actually painted by Giacomo Antonio Melchiorre Ceruti, another Italian artist. Experts valued the painting at approximately $290,000.
How the portrait came into Friedrich Kadgien's hands remains unclear. Kadgien handled foreign currency, precious metals, and the sale of confiscated property for the Nazi regime—the financial machinery that made the looting possible. After Germany's defeat, he fled first to Switzerland, then to Argentina, where he lived until his death in 1978 without ever facing arrest or prosecution for war crimes. His daughter Patricia and her husband, Juan Carlos Cortegoso, were charged after authorities discovered they had concealed the painting despite knowing that Argentine and international investigators were actively searching for it.
Instead of proceeding to trial, Patricia Kadgien agreed to surrender all claims to the work. Judge Santiago Inchausti approved the arrangement on Friday, which spares her and her husband criminal conviction in exchange for two years of court supervision, mandatory payments to a hospital in Mar del Plata, and the requirement to keep authorities informed of their location. The agreement clears the path for the painting's return to Maril von Saher, the sole surviving heir of Goudstikker's collection. Von Saher, who now lives in Greenwich, Connecticut, has spent decades pursuing the recovery of her family's looted art. Her lawyers indicated she has consented to allow the painting to be exhibited in Argentina before it is transferred to her.
The recovery represents a small but significant victory in the ongoing effort to trace and return artworks stolen during the Nazi era. During raids on properties owned by Kadgien and her sister in Mar del Plata last year, Argentine police also seized two additional 19th-century paintings along with various prints and engravings. Authorities continue investigating whether any of these works may also have been taken during World War II, suggesting that the full scope of what was hidden in Argentina may not yet be known.
Notable Quotes
Goudstikker was one of Europe's leading art dealers before World War II, known for a collection that included works by Rembrandt and Vermeer.— Court records and art historical documentation
Want the full story?
Read the original at CBS News ↗
Crime & Justice