Less than eighteen months into his chancellorship, Friedrich Merz finds himself at the center of a quiet but deepening crisis of political legitimacy — one that raises an enduring question about democratic leadership: when a leader's style becomes the story, can the substance of governance survive? The CDU, once a pillar of German political stability, is watching its support erode to historic lows as the far-right AfD fills the space it leaves behind. Merz has canceled his appearance at the United Nations to remain in Berlin and seek an explicit vote of confidence from his own party — a rare a
Merz fights to retain CDU leadership as party hemorrhages support to AfD
Support for his own party has dropped by half instead
Mark
So Merz promised to cut AfD support in half and instead his own party's support dropped by half. That's a remarkable inversion. What happened?
Mimi
He took office in May 2025 with a mandate to address the far-right threat. But his approach—his tone, his impatience with difficult reforms—seems to have alienated voters rather than reassured them. The pension reform is a good example. It requires real sacrifice from people, but he sounds frustrated when he talks about it, not sympathetic.
Luke
But we should be careful here. The source attributes this to his "communication style" and "lack of empathy," but those are interpretations from critics and commentators. We don't have polling data showing what voters actually cite as their reason for abandoning the CDU. The AfD's gains could be driven by other factors entirely.
Mark
Fair point. But Karin Prien is from his own party, and she said publicly that people feel the chancellor lacks empathy. That's not speculation—that's a cabinet member naming the problem.
Mimi
Right. And in July he made that comment about work-life balance threatening prosperity, which unions read as calling Germans lazy. That's a concrete moment where his words created real damage.
Luke
True, but again—we're seeing how critics interpreted his words, not necessarily what he meant or what voters heard. The source doesn't give us direct voter testimony about what turned them away.
Mark
So the real puzzle is: why can't they replace him if he's so unpopular?
Mimi
Because there's no clear alternative. Söder provokes the CDU constantly. Wüst is competent but doesn't want the job and has his own reelection to worry about. And removing a sitting chancellor requires either his voluntary resignation or a constructive vote of no confidence—a public challenge that would tear the party apart.
Luke
And notably, all eight state premiers just issued a statement backing him. That's either genuine support or a coordinated effort to prevent a leadership vacuum. The source doesn't tell us which.
Mark
So he's trapped and they're trapped.
Mimi
Exactly. He's calling an emergency executive committee meeting for Sunday, after the next state election results. He's canceling his UN trip to stay in Berlin. He's essentially asking his party: do you still want me?
Luke
But that's a high-wire act. If the party says no, he's finished. If they say yes, it buys him time but doesn't solve the underlying problem—voters are still leaving.
Mark
What happens if Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania goes as badly as expected?
Mimi
Then the pressure becomes almost unbearable. The CDU could fail to clear the 5 percent threshold entirely. At that point, even a show of party loyalty might not be enough to keep him in office.
Luke
And we won't know any of that until after September 20. Everything happening now is prelude.
The Pulse
- The CDU's support has collapsed to just 7% ahead of the September 20 state election in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, putting the party at risk of falling below the parliamentary threshold entirely.
- Critics within and beyond the party say Merz's impatient tone — particularly on pension reform and his remarks about German work culture — has made voters feel judged rather than heard.
- The AfD, designated as confirmed right-wing extremist by German intelligence, is winning the elections Merz once promised to make irrelevant, inverting his central political pledge.
- No credible successor has stepped forward: Söder divides the party, and Wüst has shown no desire to leave North Rhine-Westphalia, leaving the CDU trapped between loyalty and doubt.
- All eight CDU state premiers have issued a joint statement of support, but their call for 'listening and political action, not personnel debates' reads as much like a warning as an endorsement.
- Merz has scrapped his UN General Assembly trip and plans to face his party's executive committee directly on Sunday — staking his chancellorship on whether 22 senior conservatives still believe in him.
Less than eighteen months into his chancellorship, Friedrich Merz finds himself at the center of a quiet but deepening crisis of political legitimacy — one that raises an enduring question about democratic leadership: when a leader's style becomes the story, can the substance of governance survive? The CDU, once a pillar of German political stability, is watching its support erode to historic lows as the far-right AfD fills the space it leaves behind. Merz has canceled his appearance at the United Nations to remain in Berlin and seek an explicit vote of confidence from his own party — a rare and telling act of political vulnerability.
Friedrich Merz was standing at a European Arctic Summit in Finland when reporters asked him whether he still had the confidence of his country. The distance from Berlin offered no shelter. Eighteen months after taking office as German chancellor, Merz is confronting a political crisis that has turned inward — one that is as much about how he leads as what he has done.
The immediate trigger is a string of state election disasters. The CDU lost badly in Saxony-Anhalt, where the AfD — formally classified by German intelligence as a confirmed right-wing extremist organization — took first place. Now, with another election approaching in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania on September 20, the CDU is polling at just 7 percent, perilously close to the threshold for parliamentary representation. Before his election, Merz had vowed to cut AfD support in half. Instead, it is his own party's numbers that have been halved.
The criticism of Merz is pointed and personal. Education Minister Karin Prien said publicly that citizens feel the chancellor and his party lack empathy. His comments about Germany's work-life balance culture were read by trade unions as an accusation of laziness. When explaining painful pension reforms, he has often come across as impatient rather than compassionate. Coalition partner the SPD is openly urging the CDU to steady itself.
Yet the party finds itself in a political trap. There is no obvious replacement. Markus Söder is too divisive. Hendrik Wüst, widely respected, has no interest in leaving his state ahead of his own reelection campaign. Removing Merz against his will would require a constructive vote of no confidence — a confrontation no one is willing to start.
On Wednesday, all eight CDU state premiers signed a joint statement backing Merz and calling for unity over personnel debates. The message was supportive in form, but its subtext was clear: the party needs to stop the bleeding. Merz, for his part, has canceled his trip to the United Nations General Assembly and plans to convene the CDU's 22-member executive committee on Sunday evening, once the Mecklenburg results are known. He intends to ask them directly whether they still trust him — a question that, in German politics, rarely gets asked unless the answer is genuinely uncertain.
Friedrich Merz was in Rovaniemi, Finland, nearly 1,800 kilometers north of Berlin, when journalists asked him about the political storm gathering in the German capital. The chancellor had come to the European Arctic Summit to discuss natural resources, geopolitics, and climate security. But even that distance could not shield him from the question that now dominates German politics: Is he still the right person for the job?
Merz took office as German chancellor in May 2025. Less than eighteen months later, his government's public approval has hit a record low, and his own party, the Christian Democratic Union, is hemorrhaging support. The most immediate wound came from the state election in Saxony-Anhalt, where the CDU suffered what observers are calling a crushing defeat. The Alternative for Germany, classified by the domestic intelligence agency as "confirmed right-wing extremist," won the race instead. Worse still, another state election looms on September 20 in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, where the CDU is polling at just 7 percent—dangerously close to the 5 percent threshold needed to enter the state parliament. Party officials are bracing for what could be the worst state election result in CDU history.
Before his election, Merz had promised to cut AfD support in half. Instead, support for his own party has dropped by half. The question circulating through Berlin's political circles is blunt: Is this Merz's doing? Observers point to his often sharp communication style and his apparent difficulty in explaining complex reforms—particularly the contentious changes to the state pension system. Education Minister Karin Prien, also a CDU member, said publicly on the broadcaster ARD that many citizens feel the chancellor and his party "lack the necessary empathy." In July, Merz had complained that German attitudes about a four-day workweek and work-life balance could threaten national prosperity, language that trade unions interpreted as calling Germans lazy. Commentators note that when discussing painful pension cuts, the chancellor often sounds impatient rather than understanding.
Behind closed doors, government officials speak even more plainly about the crisis of confidence in the Merz cabinet. The SPD, the junior coalition partner, has begun sounding alarms. Dirk Wiese, the SPD's parliamentary secretary, told the Welt TV channel that "nerves are a bit frayed in the CDU right now" and appealed to the coalition partner to "get back on track."
Yet the party faces a paralyzing problem: there is no obvious successor. Markus Söder, the Bavarian state premier and leader of the CDU's sister party, the Christian Social Union, has been mentioned as a possible candidate. But he frequently provokes the CDU and lacks broad support within the party. Hendrik Wüst, the CDU state premier of North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany's most populous state, has led a coalition with the Greens capably for over four years. But he has shown little appetite for moving to Berlin and plans to run for reelection in his state next April. Technically, if the coalition agreed to remove Merz, a successor could be appointed by parliamentary majority in the Bundestag. But if Merz refuses to step down voluntarily, a "constructive vote of no confidence" would be required—a confrontation no one in the party appears willing to initiate.
On Wednesday, all eight CDU state premiers issued a joint statement declaring their continued support for Merz. They called for unity within the party and said that rebuilding voter trust required "listening and political action, not personnel debates." Germany needed "stability more than ever," they wrote. The statement was signed by Daniel Günther of Schleswig-Holstein, Boris Rhein of Hesse, Sven Schulze of Saxony-Anhalt, Kai Wegner of Berlin, Michael Kretschmer of Saxony, Gordon Schnieder of Rhineland-Palatinate, Mario Voigt of Thuringia, and Wüst of North Rhine-Westphalia.
Merz appears to be taking the crisis seriously. According to reports circulating in Berlin political circles, he plans to convene the CDU's executive committee—a group of 22 leading conservative politicians—as early as Sunday evening, once the Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania results are in. He intends to ask them directly whether the party still trusts him. The chancellor has canceled his planned trip to the United Nations General Assembly, a high-profile engagement scheduled well in advance. Government sources confirmed he will remain in Berlin because he is "needed" there. The question now is whether that show of commitment will be enough to stabilize his position, or whether the party's losses will force a reckoning he cannot control.
Notable Quotes
Many people feel that the chancellor and we in the CDU/CSU lack the necessary empathy, and that has to change.— Education Minister Karin Prien, CDU
You really get the impression that nerves are a bit frayed in the CDU right now. I can only appeal once again to our coalition partner to really get back on track.— SPD Parliamentary Secretary Dirk Wiese
Want the full story?
Read the original at Deutsche Welle ↗
Climate & Environment