Israel marks three years since October 7 Hamas attack amid ongoing Gaza conflict

Approximately 1,200 Israelis killed on October 7, 2023; 251 taken hostage; over 74,200 Palestinians killed in subsequent Gaza war; 2.1 million Gazans displaced with dire humanitarian conditions; 1.2 million living in tents or shelters.
They have turned Gaza into a place that is almost impossible to live in
A displaced Palestinian barber expresses his fear that Gaza has been deliberately rendered uninhabitable after three years of war.
Mark

What strikes you most about how Israel is marking this anniversary?

Mimi

The weight of it—three years, and families are still gathering at the exact places where their loved ones were killed. The Nova festival, the kibbutzim. It's not abstract grief. It's place-based, rooted in the ground.

Luke

But we should note: this is the first anniversary with no hostages left in Gaza. That's a factual shift. The ceasefire was supposed to change things, but it hasn't.

Mark

Why hasn't the ceasefire held?

Mimi

The source doesn't give us the mechanics of why it failed—just that it has. Over 1,460 Palestinians killed since it took effect, near-daily Israeli strikes continuing. The ceasefire exists on paper but not in practice.

Luke

Right. And we don't know from this reporting whose actions broke it or under what circumstances. We know it's broken. We don't know the full story of how.

Mark

What about Netanyahu's position on accountability?

Mimi

He's refused to establish an independent inquiry into the security failures that allowed October 7 to happen. He says the Supreme Court would be biased against him. But many senior officials have already resigned or been fired.

Luke

That's important: there's been turnover and consequences, just not a formal, independent investigation. The absence of inquiry is a choice he's made and is defending.

Mark

The numbers from Gaza are staggering. How do we hold those in mind?

Mimi

74,200 killed according to Gaza's health ministry—figures the UN trusts. 80 percent of structures destroyed. 1.2 million people in tents or shelters. And people like Mohammed the barber, displaced five times, afraid they're being pushed out entirely.

Luke

The UN figures on destruction and displacement are solid. The death toll comes from Gaza's health ministry, which the UN considers reliable, but it's still one source. We should be clear about that attribution.

Mark

Are Palestinians saying they're being forced out?

Mimi

Not officially—but the fear is there. Mohammed said he doesn't believe the destruction happened for nothing, that Gaza's been made uninhabitable. Atta described Palestinians as "living in graves while still alive." These are people expressing a fear, not stating a confirmed policy.

Luke

Exactly. The fear is real and documented. Whether there's an explicit expulsion plan is a different question the reporting doesn't answer.

Mark

How did the world respond?

Mimi

International leaders—Germany, the UK, the EU, the US—all reaffirmed support for Israel and called for peace. The EU specifically mentioned a two-state solution. But it's ceremonial language, mostly.

Luke

It is. And Hamas released a statement calling October 7 a "historic milestone." That's also in the record. The reporting gives us both sides' framing without resolving the deeper conflict.

  • Survivors and bereaved families gathered at the Nova festival site and kibbutz cemeteries to speak the names of 1,200 dead, while a father who survived captivity apologized to his wife and sons who did not.
  • Prime Minister Netanyahu vowed continued military retribution at the national memorial, even as protesters dyed a Tel Aviv fountain red and held banners calling his government guilty of catastrophic security failures.
  • A ceasefire agreed nearly a year ago has effectively collapsed — more than 1,460 Palestinians killed since it took effect, Israeli strikes continuing into Wednesday itself, and no political framework capable of holding.
  • Gaza's 2.1 million displaced residents face a landscape where 80 percent of structures are destroyed, over 60 million tonnes of rubble remain, and a barber displaced five times fears his homeland has been deliberately made unlivable.
  • International leaders reaffirmed solidarity with Israel and called for a two-state solution, while Hamas described October 7 as a historic milestone — leaving the gap between any durable peace and the present reality as wide as ever.

Three years after Hamas-led gunmen killed approximately 1,200 Israelis and took 251 hostage in a single morning, Israel paused to grieve at the places where the dead fell — festival grounds, kibbutz cemeteries, public squares — while the war that followed continues to consume Gaza. The anniversary arrives not as a closing chapter but as a marker within an ongoing catastrophe: more than 74,200 Palestinians killed, a ceasefire collapsed, and two peoples caught in a cycle of loss that no ceremony has yet found the power to interrupt. In grief, nations often search for meaning; here, the search itself remains unresolved.

Israel paused on Wednesday to mark three years since Hamas-led gunmen crossed the border and killed roughly 1,200 people in a coordinated assault that reshaped the region. Families gathered at the sites where their loved ones died — the Nova dance festival near Kibbutz Re'im, where 378 people were shot and killed, and the kibbutzim along the perimeter — to lay flowers and speak the names of the dead.

At Nova, Ahuva Yavin Mayze mourned her 21-year-old daughter Adi. Former Israeli footballer Shlomo Sharf came to remember his granddaughter May Naim. Yarden Bibas, himself a former hostage, addressed his wife Shiri and their two young sons — Ariel and Kfir — who were taken from Kibbutz Nir Oz and later died in captivity. "Sorry," he said. "Sorry that you are up there and I am here." At Kibbutz Kfar Aza, where 64 residents were killed and 19 taken hostage, a community leader noted that most survivors had still not returned home.

Prime Minister Netanyahu attended the national memorial in Tel Aviv, vowing to "complete the mission" and settle scores with those responsible. Yet he faced protesters demanding an independent state inquiry into the security failures that allowed the attack to occur. No such inquiry has been established. In Dizengoff Square, demonstrators dyed a fountain red and held banners reading "a complete failure" beside his image.

The assault triggered a military response that has since killed more than 74,200 Palestinians, according to figures the UN considers reliable. A ceasefire agreed nearly a year ago has not held — more than 1,460 people have been killed in Gaza since it took effect. Nearly all of Gaza's 2.1 million residents remain displaced, with 80 percent of structures destroyed or damaged and 1.2 million people living in tents or shelters.

Mohammed Emad al-Din, a barber in Gaza City displaced five times, told the BBC he fears Gaza has been deliberately rendered uninhabitable. "They have turned Gaza into a place that is almost impossible to live in," he said. Another displaced Palestinian described his community as "living in graves while still alive," having lost a son, daughter, and sister to the war.

International leaders marked the anniversary with statements of solidarity and calls for a two-state solution. Hamas called October 7 a "historic milestone." On Wednesday itself, Israeli strikes in northern and southern Gaza killed at least three Palestinians. The war continues without resolution.

Israel paused on Wednesday to mark three years since the morning Hamas-led gunmen crossed the border and killed roughly 1,200 people in a coordinated assault that would reshape the region. Families gathered at the sites where their loved ones died—the Nova dance festival in the south, the kibbutzim along the perimeter—to lay flowers and speak the names of the dead. The attack had taken 251 people hostage. Now, three years later, none remained in Gaza.

At the Nova festival grounds near Kibbutz Re'im, where 378 people were shot and killed on October 7, 2023, survivors and bereaved families stood together on Wednesday morning. Ahuva Yavin Mayze, whose 21-year-old daughter Adi was among them, described what occurred there as dystopic and unimaginable. Shlomo Sharf, a former Israeli footballer, came to remember his granddaughter May Naim, 24, also killed at the festival. Yarden Bibas, who had been taken hostage himself and later released, spoke of his wife Shiri and two young sons, Ariel and Kfir, who were kidnapped from their home in Kibbutz Nir Oz and later died in captivity in Gaza. He told the Times of Israel: "Sorry. Sorry that you are up there and I am here."

At Kibbutz Kfar Aza, where 64 residents were killed and 19 taken hostage, the small cemetery filled with mourners. Zion Regev, a community leader, said most survivors had not returned to their homes because of the trauma. "This is the first time we are doing all the things here in the kibbutz," he told Reuters. "It's a very emotional day, it's a very difficult day for our community, three years after 7 October."

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attended the national memorial ceremony at Tel Aviv's Yarkon Park on Wednesday evening. He said Israel would remember those "who knew that they had to give their lives in order to save others." In a statement released that afternoon, Netanyahu said he had lit a memorial candle for every victim. "We will complete the mission: we have settled the score and will continue settling the score with all the murderers," he added. At a ceremony on Monday, he claimed Israel had killed 4,000 of the roughly 6,000 Palestinians who infiltrated from Gaza that day. Yet Netanyahu faced protesters demanding an independent state inquiry into the security failures that allowed the attack to succeed. Many senior Israeli defence and security officials have resigned or been fired since October 7, but there has been no independent commission of inquiry. Netanyahu has rejected personal responsibility and refused to establish a state inquiry led by Israel's Supreme Court, arguing the judiciary would be biased against him. In Tel Aviv's Dizengoff Square, anti-government protesters dyed the fountain red and held banners reading "a complete failure" and "guilty" next to his image.

The assault triggered a military response that has reshaped Gaza. Israel's offensive has killed more than 74,200 people according to the Hamas-run health ministry, figures the UN considers reliable. A ceasefire agreed almost a year ago has not held. Violence continues. More than 1,460 people have been killed in Gaza since the ceasefire took effect, according to Gaza's health ministry. The Israeli military says at least seven Israeli soldiers have been killed in the strip over the same period. Nearly all of Gaza's 2.1 million population remain displaced. An estimated 80 percent of all structures have been destroyed or damaged, leaving more than 60 million tonnes of rubble and 1.2 million people living in tents or shelters, according to the UN.

Mohammed Emad al-Din, a 38-year-old barber in Gaza City, has been displaced five times. His home was destroyed and his shop partially damaged. He told the BBC he fears Gaza has been deliberately rendered uninhabitable. "I don't believe Israel caused all this destruction for nothing," he said. "They have turned Gaza into a place that is almost impossible to live in, and I fear that we will eventually end up outside the place where we were born." Another displaced Palestinian, Atta Saeed Hassan Shweikh, said his son, daughter, sister and her children had all been killed during the war. Speaking from Gaza City, he described Palestinians as "living in graves while still alive."

International leaders marked the anniversary. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz called October 7 a "profound rupture" and said antisemitism must be confronted with "even greater resolve." UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham told Britain's Jewish community: "We stand with you." Ursula von der Leyen, president of the European Commission, said the "unspeakable savagery and terror of 7 October must never happen again" and said the EU "remains ready to help turn today's fragile ceasefire into a durable peace, based on a two-state solution." US President Donald Trump told reporters he had spoken to Netanyahu and called October 7 "a horrible day, a horrible tragedy."

Hamas released a statement calling the October 7 attack a "historic milestone" in its "ongoing struggle project" and described it as "a natural response" to "bitter suffering" imposed by Israel. On Wednesday, Israeli strikes in the northern town of Beit Lahia and the southern city of Khan Younis killed at least three Palestinians, medics said. The Israeli military said it struck two Hamas operatives in northern Gaza overnight, one of whom it accused of planting explosives near the Yellow Line marking territory still occupied by Israeli forces. The war continues without resolution.

I don't believe Israel caused all this destruction for nothing. They have turned Gaza into a place that is almost impossible to live in, and I fear that we will eventually end up outside the place where we were born.
— Mohammed Emad al-Din, displaced Palestinian barber in Gaza City
This is the first time we are doing all the things here in the kibbutz. It's a very emotional day, it's a very difficult day for our community, three years after 7 October.
— Zion Regev, community leader at Kibbutz Kfar Aza
Quer a matéria completa? Leia o original em BBC News ↗
Fale Conosco FAQ