In the volatile terrain of mid- and smallcap markets, ICICI Prudential's chief investment officer Sankaran Naren is practicing an old and demanding art: finding value precisely where others have given up looking. His contrarian thesis holds that the most beaten-down securities carry the greatest asymmetric potential, provided one possesses the rarest of investor virtues — patience. It is a philosophy that asks participants to trust process over sentiment, and time over trend.
ICICI Prudential's Naren Spots Contrarian Plays in Beaten-Down Mid, Smallcaps
Only buy the underperformers, and wait for the market to catch up
Mark
So Naren is saying the best opportunities right now are in stocks that have already lost the most ground. Why would that be true?
Mimi
Because when a stock has fallen hard, most of the bad news is already priced in. The people who were going to panic-sell have already sold. What's left is the possibility that either the company recovers or the market's perception of it shifts.
Luke
But we should be careful here—the source doesn't give us specific examples of which mid- or smallcap stocks Naren is actually buying. We know the philosophy, but not the portfolio.
Mark
Fair point. So how does this actually protect investors during a downturn?
Mimi
Contrarian funds have historically held up better than benchmarks when markets fall because they're already holding the depressed stuff. There's less distance to fall when you're already at the bottom.
Luke
That's the historical claim, but it's worth noting the source doesn't provide specific performance data or time periods. It's a general statement about how contrarian funds have behaved.
Mark
And the patience thing—how long are we talking about?
Mimi
The source doesn't specify. It just says long-term. Could be a year, could be five years. That's the real risk: you have to be able to wait without knowing exactly how long.
Luke
Right. And that's where the strategy breaks down for most retail investors. The theory is sound, but the execution requires a temperament most people don't have.
Mark
So Naren's essentially betting that he can identify which beaten-down stocks will bounce back?
Mimi
Exactly. He's saying ICICI Prudential will only buy the underperformers—the ones the market has given up on. The skill is in picking the right ones.
Luke
Which brings us back to the gap between philosophy and proof. We have the investment thesis, but no track record specific to this current market environment or these specific holdings.
O Pulso
- Mid- and smallcap segments are littered with abandoned stocks, and Naren sees this neglect not as a warning sign but as the opportunity itself.
- The tension is real: contrarian positions can languish for months or years, testing investor resolve while benchmarks and momentum plays attract the crowd.
- ICICI Prudential is deploying capital selectively, targeting only those securities where prior selling has already absorbed much of the downside risk.
- The critical distinction — between a stock that is cheap because it is overlooked versus one that is cheap because it is broken — is where the strategy's success or failure will ultimately be decided.
- Historically, contrarian funds have cushioned losses during downturns better than benchmarks, lending credibility to the approach even as short-term results may disappoint.
- The strategy's fate rests as much on investor temperament as on fund manager skill — those who cannot endure underperformance will exit before the thesis has time to prove itself.
In the volatile terrain of mid- and smallcap markets, ICICI Prudential's chief investment officer Sankaran Naren is practicing an old and demanding art: finding value precisely where others have given up looking. His contrarian thesis holds that the most beaten-down securities carry the greatest asymmetric potential, provided one possesses the rarest of investor virtues — patience. It is a philosophy that asks participants to trust process over sentiment, and time over trend.
Sankaran Naren, chief investment officer at ICICI Prudential Asset Management, has turned his attention to a corner of the market most investors are actively fleeing: the mid- and smallcap stocks that have lagged furthest behind their benchmarks. His argument is that these are precisely the securities where contrarian value accumulates — not despite their unpopularity, but because of it.
Contrarian investing runs deliberately against the grain. Where most participants chase momentum and crowd into favored holdings, contrarian funds seek out the unloved and the abandoned. The historical record offers some vindication: during market downturns, when sentiment sours and prices fall broadly, stocks that were already depressed tend to fall less far than those still riding high expectations.
Naren's approach at ICICI Prudential is selective by design. The fund focuses on underperforming securities where depressed valuations create an asymmetry — much of the downside has already been absorbed by prior sellers, while recovery potential remains intact should fundamentals improve or sentiment shift. It is, at its core, a bet on mean reversion.
The strategy's greatest demand, however, is not analytical but psychological. Contrarian positions can remain out of favor for extended periods, and investors who measure success quarterly or panic during continued underperformance will abandon the approach before it has time to work. Naren is clear: patience is not incidental to this strategy — it is the strategy.
The harder question is whether every beaten-down stock deserves rescue. Some are cheap for legitimate reasons, and the skill lies in separating the genuinely undervalued from the genuinely impaired. Whether ICICI Prudential can consistently make that distinction — and whether its investors can endure the wait — will determine how this contrarian chapter ultimately reads.
Sankaran Naren, the chief investment officer at ICICI Prudential Asset Management, has identified pockets of opportunity in the mid- and smallcap segments of the market—but not where most investors are looking. His thesis is straightforward: the stocks that have been beaten down the hardest, the ones that have lagged furthest behind their benchmarks, are precisely where contrarian value can be found. The catch, he warns, is that this kind of investing demands patience from the people who put their money into it.
Contrarian funds operate on a principle that runs counter to the instinct of most market participants. Rather than chasing momentum or following the crowd into popular holdings, they deliberately seek out the unloved securities—the stocks that have fallen out of favor, that investors have abandoned, that the market has essentially written off. This approach has a documented track record: during periods when markets stumble and sentiment turns sour, contrarian funds have historically cushioned losses better than their benchmarks. When everything else is falling, the stocks that were already down often fall less far.
Naren's strategy at ICICI Prudential reflects this philosophy. The fund house is being selective about where it deploys capital in the mid- and smallcap space, focusing specifically on securities that have underperformed. The logic is that these depressed valuations create an asymmetry: the downside risk has already been largely absorbed by previous sellers, while the upside potential—should sentiment shift or fundamentals improve—remains substantial. It is a bet on mean reversion, on the idea that what has been beaten down will eventually recover.
But this approach is not for investors who need to see results quickly. Contrarian investing by its nature requires a long holding period. The stocks that are most despised today may remain despised for months or even years before the market's perception shifts. An investor who buys into a contrarian fund and then checks their returns quarterly, or who panics when the holdings continue to lag in the short term, will likely abandon the strategy before it has time to work. The patience required is not merely a nice-to-have; it is foundational to whether the strategy succeeds or fails.
What Naren is essentially saying is that ICICI Prudential will only buy the underperformers—the stocks that have disappointed, that have missed expectations, that the market has moved past. This selectivity matters. Not every beaten-down stock is a bargain; some are cheap for good reason. The skill lies in distinguishing between the genuinely undervalued and the genuinely broken. Naren's track record and the resources of ICICI Prudential suggest they believe they can make that distinction. Whether investors have the temperament to stick with such a strategy through the inevitable periods of underperformance remains an open question.
Citações Notáveis
Pockets of the mid- and smallcap space now offer contrarian opportunities, but investors must be patient— Sankaran Naren, ICICI Prudential AMC
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em Moneycontrol.com ↗
Economy & Finance