As the United States entered its first government shutdown in nearly seven years, global financial markets responded not with alarm but with a kind of studied indifference — even climbing to record highs. Beneath the calm, traders were reading the labor market's quiet signals: slowing private payrolls and contracting factory activity pointed toward Federal Reserve rate cuts, which markets welcomed as a cushion against political turbulence. The shutdown's true weight, economists cautioned, would only be felt if it stretched long enough to turn temporary disruption into permanent job losses — a
Global stocks hit records as markets brush aside US shutdown threat
Markets are betting on rate cuts, not bracing for crisis.
Mark
So the market hit new highs while the government shut down. That seems like it shouldn't happen at the same time.
Mimi
Right, but traders decided the shutdown wasn't the main story. The real story was the labor market weakening—fewer jobs being created, factories shrinking for seven months straight.
Luke
But we don't actually know how weak the labor market is, do we? The official jobs report is delayed because of the shutdown.
Mimi
Exactly. So traders are relying on private data—the ADP payroll survey, the manufacturing index. And that private data is pointing to weakness.
Mark
Which makes the Fed more likely to cut rates?
Mimi
Yes. Two more cuts this year, traders are betting. That's good for stocks in the near term.
Luke
But there's a threat here that nobody's really pricing in yet—the administration said it might lay off federal workers permanently if the shutdown lasts.
Mimi
Right. That could actually slow the economy more than a typical shutdown would.
Mark
So why aren't stocks falling?
Luke
Because traders think either it won't happen, or it won't last long enough to matter. But that's an assumption, not a fact.
Mimi
And if the shutdown does extend and layoffs do happen, the spillover into equities could be real.
Mark
So we're watching to see if the shutdown becomes something more than a political theater piece.
Luke
Exactly. For now, markets are betting it doesn't. But that bet could be wrong.
The Pulse
- The US government shut down for the first time in nearly seven years, yet the S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 both closed at record highs, signaling that traders had, at least provisionally, decided Washington's impasse was not their problem.
- Private payroll data revealed an unexpected drop in September hiring, adding to a pattern of slowing employment growth that the shutdown itself threatened to obscure by delaying the official government jobs report.
- The hiring weakness paradoxically buoyed markets — traders increased bets on two more Federal Reserve rate cuts this year, sending Treasury yields lower and reinforcing the view that monetary easing would absorb the economic friction.
- A sharper threat lurked in White House signals that federal layoffs could follow if the shutdown persisted, with Budget Director Russell Vought reportedly preparing to move quickly — a risk analysts flagged as potentially more damaging than any prior shutdown.
- Asian futures climbed Thursday morning and commodity markets held steady, suggesting the optimism was not confined to Wall Street — though analysts warned that a prolonged shutdown or large-scale federal job cuts could rapidly change the calculus.
As the United States entered its first government shutdown in nearly seven years, global financial markets responded not with alarm but with a kind of studied indifference — even climbing to record highs. Beneath the calm, traders were reading the labor market's quiet signals: slowing private payrolls and contracting factory activity pointed toward Federal Reserve rate cuts, which markets welcomed as a cushion against political turbulence. The shutdown's true weight, economists cautioned, would only be felt if it stretched long enough to turn temporary disruption into permanent job losses — a threshold the world was watching, but had not yet reached.
Global stock markets closed Wednesday at record highs, a striking milestone given that the first US government shutdown in nearly seven years had just taken effect. The S&P 500 rose 0.3% and the Nasdaq 100 gained 0.5%, lifting both benchmarks and a broad measure of global equities to new peaks. Traders appeared to have concluded, at least for now, that the political standoff in Washington posed no immediate threat to their portfolios.
The deeper story was in the labor market. Private payroll data showed an unexpected drop in September hiring, consistent with seven consecutive months of contraction in factory activity. These figures carried extra weight because the shutdown threatened to delay the official government employment report the Federal Reserve depends on for rate decisions. With that data potentially unavailable, policymakers and traders would have to reconstruct the labor picture from private surveys alone — a vacuum that markets moved quickly to interpret as a signal for easing.
Treasury yields fell, with the 10-year note dropping to around 4.1%, as traders increased bets on two more Fed rate cuts before year's end. Economists at Berenberg argued that even without the official September jobs report, the Fed would have enough information to justify a quarter-point cut at its October meeting.
What distinguished this shutdown from previous ones was the specter of permanent layoffs. Vice President JD Vance said he did not expect a prolonged closure, but warned that job cuts would follow if it lasted days or weeks. Some analysts viewed this as political posturing; others flagged it as a genuine economic risk. Thomas Ryan of Capital Economics noted that permanent reductions in federal payrolls could extend the drag on employment well beyond what earlier shutdowns had caused.
Equity traders remained unmoved. Citigroup's Stuart Kaiser said the shutdown would need to last considerably longer, produce substantial layoffs, or spill into the bond market before it meaningfully threatened stocks. Asian futures climbed early Thursday, gold edged to a new high, and Bitcoin rose modestly — a portrait of markets in equilibrium, betting on rate cuts and treating the political crisis as a temporary inconvenience. Whether that confidence would hold if the shutdown deepened remained the question no one had yet been forced to answer.
Global stock markets closed Wednesday at record highs, a milestone that arrived despite the first US government shutdown in nearly seven years taking effect. The S&P 500 rose 0.3% and the Nasdaq 100 gained 0.5%, lifting both benchmarks and a broad measure of global shares to new peaks. The indifference was striking: traders appeared to have decided, at least for now, that the political standoff in Washington posed no immediate threat to their portfolios.
The real story underneath the market calm was the labor market. Private payroll data released Wednesday showed an unexpected drop in September hiring at US companies, a sign consistent with other recent indicators that employment growth is slowing. Factory activity had contracted for seven consecutive months. These figures mattered precisely because the shutdown threatened to delay the official government employment report that the Federal Reserve relies on to make interest rate decisions. With that data potentially unavailable, traders and policymakers would have to piece together the labor picture from private reports like the ADP payroll survey and purchasing managers indexes.
The weakness in hiring data pushed traders to increase their bets on two additional Federal Reserve rate cuts before year's end. Treasury yields fell, with the 10-year note dropping five basis points to around 4.1%. Economists at Berenberg argued that even without the September nonfarm payroll report, Fed officials would have sufficient information about the labor market to justify another quarter-point cut at their October meeting. The shutdown, in other words, had created a vacuum that private data was rushing to fill.
What made this shutdown potentially different from previous ones was the threat of permanent job losses. Vice President JD Vance said at a White House press conference Wednesday that he did not expect a prolonged closure, but added that layoffs would follow if the shutdown lasted days or weeks. The White House Budget Director Russell Vought was preparing to move swiftly in dismissing federal workers. Some analysts saw this as political posturing subject to legal challenge, but others flagged it as a genuine risk to the economy. Thomas Ryan, an economist at Capital Economics, noted that permanent reductions in federal payrolls could extend the drag on employment beyond what previous shutdowns had caused.
Yet equity traders remained unmoved. Stuart Kaiser, Citigroup's head of US equity trading strategy, said on Bloomberg Television that for the shutdown to meaningfully hurt stocks, it would need to last considerably longer, produce substantial layoffs, or trigger some spillover effect into the bond market that would then ripple into equities. For now, none of those conditions appeared to be materializing. Asian equity futures climbed early Thursday—Australian futures rose 0.5%, while Japanese and Hong Kong futures edged higher—suggesting the optimism was spreading across time zones.
In the currency and commodity markets, movement was muted. The dollar held steady, gold rose fractionally to a new high, and oil dipped slightly as traders weighed the possibility that OPEC+ might accelerate production increases even as US crude inventories grew. Bitcoin rose 0.3% to just under $118,000, while Ether fell 0.4%. The broader message was one of equilibrium: markets were pricing in a slowdown in US hiring, betting on Fed rate cuts as a response, and shrugging off the political crisis as a temporary inconvenience. Whether that confidence would hold if the shutdown extended or federal layoffs materialized at scale remained an open question.
Notable Quotes
The market will have to focus on independent private sources to get a sense of what's going on, and if the administration cuts head count, there is potential for economic impact.— Brij Khurana, Wellington Management portfolio manager
For this to really impact equity markets you're going to need it to last for a while, you're going to need to see pretty large layoffs or something happen in the bond market.— Stuart Kaiser, Citigroup head of US equity trading strategy
Want the full story?
Read the original at Swissinfo (EN) ↗
Economy & Finance