Every era of greatness carries within it the quiet question of what comes after. Harry Kane, at 33, continues to rewrite England's record books — 91 goals, 125 caps, a domestic double with Bayern Munich — yet the arithmetic of time has prompted manager Thomas Tuchel to look beyond the irreplaceable toward the merely excellent. The search for a successor is less a crisis than a reckoning: England must decide whether it seeks another Kane, or learns to imagine a different kind of striker altogether.
England's Kane succession puzzle: Is Bellingham the answer or does a replacement await?
You will not get another Harry Kane. We look for different options.
Mark
So Bellingham is the obvious answer, then? He's already scoring at a different rate since the World Cup.
Mimi
He's the most obvious answer Tuchel has, yes. But there's a real difference between playing as an advanced midfielder who can finish and being a true centre-forward. Bellingham's gift is his range—he can drop deep, he can surge forward. Kane does that too, but Kane is also a pure finisher in the box.
Luke
How much of Bellingham's goal surge is about him playing differently versus just playing better? Ten goals in 12 matches is a huge jump. Is that sustainable, or is it a hot streak?
Mimi
That's fair. We don't know yet. The sample size since the World Cup is small. But Tuchel clearly believes the role suits him.
Mark
What about the natural strikers? Calvert-Lewin seems like he should be the answer.
Mimi
He's the best option available right now, but he's 29 and he's not a reliable finisher. He underperformed his expected goals last season. He's a backup, not a succession plan.
Luke
And everyone else is either too old, too far away, or too young to know if they'll make it. That's the real story—England doesn't have a ready-made replacement.
Mimi
Exactly. Which is why Tuchel is also thinking about playing without a traditional striker at all.
Mark
Like Spain does?
Mimi
Like Spain does, like he did at Chelsea with Havertz. It's a different system, but it works if you have the right players.
Luke
But that's not replacing Kane. That's abandoning the position.
Mimi
It's adapting. And maybe that's what England needs to do anyway.
Mark
How long does Kane actually have left?
Mimi
He's 33 now. If he stays healthy and motivated, he could play another five or six years. Tuchel said it might be another ten years before this becomes someone else's problem.
Luke
That's a guess, though. Kane could retire tomorrow, or he could play until he's 38. We're planning for something that's completely uncertain.
Mimi
True. But that's why you start looking now, even if the answer isn't obvious yet.
Der Puls
- Kane is still breaking records at 33, but the 2028 European Championship will find him at 35, and Tuchel is already mapping the terrain beyond him.
- Jude Bellingham has surged to 10 goals in 12 matches since the 2026 World Cup, making him the most compelling candidate — yet critics argue his genius lies in playing off others, not leading the line alone.
- The conventional striker pool is alarmingly shallow: Calvert-Lewin underperforms his expected goals, Delap and Akpom have one Premier League goal each this season, and English left-backs have outscored English centre-forwards.
- Tuchel is quietly weighing a structural alternative — deploying a converted winger like Anthony Gordon, who scored 10 times in 12 Champions League appearances as a striker for Newcastle, following the blueprint Spain used to win everything.
- A generation of younger strikers — Madjo, Lankshear, Mubama — is developing in the pipeline, but none are ready, and Kane himself shows no urgency to leave, drawing inspiration from Messi's enduring brilliance.
Every era of greatness carries within it the quiet question of what comes after. Harry Kane, at 33, continues to rewrite England's record books — 91 goals, 125 caps, a domestic double with Bayern Munich — yet the arithmetic of time has prompted manager Thomas Tuchel to look beyond the irreplaceable toward the merely excellent. The search for a successor is less a crisis than a reckoning: England must decide whether it seeks another Kane, or learns to imagine a different kind of striker altogether.
Harry Kane is 33 years old, still scoring, still record-breaking — and yet English football can no longer avoid the question his excellence has long deferred. On Tuesday at Wembley, he became England's joint-highest appearance-maker, netting twice in a 3-0 win over Czechia to reach 91 goals in 125 caps. Last season he won a league and cup double with Bayern Munich, scoring 61 goals in 51 games. By almost any measure, he is in the form of his life. But when Euro 2028 arrives, he will be 35.
Thomas Tuchel is already thinking ahead. "You will not get another Harry Kane," the England manager said plainly. "We look for different options and solutions." The most prominent of those options is already in the squad: Jude Bellingham, who has scored 10 times in 12 England matches since the 2026 World Cup — a dramatic leap from six goals in his previous 48 appearances. Tuchel sees him as a potential nine, a goalscoring playmaker in the Kane mould. "He is a natural goalscorer and he has the hunger to be on the scoreboard," Tuchel said. BBC Radio 5 Live's Ian Dennis is convinced the transition is already underway: "The person who is going to replace Kane has already emerged."
Not everyone agrees. Former goalkeeper Paul Robinson argues that Bellingham's value is relational — he plays off others rather than leading the line — and that casting him as an out-and-out striker risks misreading his gifts. The debate points to a deeper problem: the conventional striker options behind Kane are thin. Dominic Calvert-Lewin, at 29, has underperformed his expected goals. Liam Delap and Chuba Akpom have one Premier League goal each this season. English left-backs have scored more than English centre-forwards.
Tuchel has a structural alternative in mind. When he managed Chelsea, he used Kai Havertz as a centre-forward to reasonable effect. Spain, the reigning world and European champions, have deployed converted wingers Oyarzabal and Torres as strikers. Anthony Gordon — who scored three times in the recent international break and 10 times in 12 Champions League appearances as a striker for Newcastle — fits that template.
Younger strikers are developing in the background: Brian Madjo at Aston Villa, Will Lankshear at Middlesbrough, Divin Mubama on loan at Southampton. None are ready now. And Kane himself, inspired by Messi's longevity, has suggested he sees no reason to set a limit on his career. Tuchel acknowledged the open horizon: "There will be someone else, but it will not be Harry or a copy of Harry. It might be another 10 years." For now, the question of succession remains exactly that — a question, patient and unresolved, waiting for the future to answer it.
Harry Kane is 33 years old and still breaking records. On Tuesday at Wembley, he became England's joint-highest appearance-maker, scoring twice in a 3-0 win over Czechia to reach 91 goals in 125 caps. He won a league and cup double with Bayern Munich last season, scoring 61 goals in 51 games. He is, by most measures, in the form of his life. And yet the question that haunts English football has become impossible to ignore: what happens when he is gone?
When the European Championship arrives in the summer of 2028, Kane will be 35. Manager Thomas Tuchel knows the arithmetic. "You will not get another Harry Kane, first of all," he said. "We look for different options and solutions." The search is already underway, and the most obvious candidate is sitting in the squad already: Jude Bellingham.
Bellingham has evolved into something more than a midfielder. Tuchel sees him as a potential nine—a striker who can also operate as a playmaker, much as Kane does. "I like him as a nine," Tuchel said ahead of England's 7-0 win over Croatia. "He is a natural goalscorer and he has the hunger to be on the scoreboard." The numbers support the instinct. Since the start of the 2026 World Cup, Bellingham has scored 10 times in 12 matches for England, a dramatic acceleration from his previous rate of six goals in 48 games. At Real Madrid, he played frequently as a false nine in his first season, with wingers providing width. Ian Dennis, BBC Radio 5 Live's senior football reporter, is convinced. "The person who is going to replace Kane has already emerged—and that's Jude Bellingham," he said. "He will also eclipse Kane in terms of appearances. This is a player who will continue to go from strength to strength."
But not everyone agrees. Former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson pushed back on the idea that Bellingham is a natural centre-forward. "He is not a nine, Bellingham plays off others," Robinson said. "I do think if England are going to play this system—and remember Kane has a long time left—I don't see Bellingham as the out and out number nine." The debate reflects a real tension: Bellingham's value lies partly in his versatility, but that same flexibility means he may not be a true replacement for Kane's specific role.
The alternative candidates are thin on the ground. Dominic Calvert-Lewin, at Leeds United, has 17 goals in 40 Premier League appearances since last summer, but he is 29 and has underperformed his expected goals. Beyond him, the cupboard is nearly bare. Liam Delap at Nottingham Forest and Chuba Akpom at Ipswich Town have each scored once in the Premier League this season. Danny Welbeck, at 35, scored 13 Premier League goals last season but is too old to be a long-term solution. Ivan Toney and Ollie Watkins, both in their thirties and now playing in Saudi Arabia, have been left out of recent squads. The gap is stark: English left-backs have scored six goals this season; English centre-forwards have scored five.
Tuchel has another option in his back pocket: abandon the traditional striker altogether. When he managed Chelsea, he deployed Kai Havertz as a centre-forward and Havertz scored 10 goals in 33 league games. Spain, the world and European champions, have used converted wingers Mikel Oyarzabal and Ferran Torres as strikers to great effect. Anthony Gordon, who scored three times during the recent international break, could fit that mold. Newcastle used him as a striker late last season and he scored 10 times in 12 Champions League appearances.
Younger strikers are emerging, though none are ready now. Brian Madjo, Aston Villa's 17-year-old, scored five goals in pre-season, including one against Paris Saint-Germain in the UEFA Super Cup, but has been sidelined by injury. Will Lankshear, a 21-year-old Tottenham academy graduate like Kane himself, has scored eight goals in 11 appearances for Middlesbrough. Manchester City's Divin Mubama, on loan at Southampton, has five goals in 10 European under-21 Championship qualifiers. Bristol City's Dom Ballard and Millwall's Josh Coburn are also watched as prospects with potential.
Kane himself has suggested he may not be in a hurry to retire. Inspired by Lionel Messi's longevity, he said after England's semi-final loss to Argentina in the summer: "As you see on the other end with Leo there, he's still performing at the highest level. So I never want to put a limit on these things." Tuchel acknowledged the uncertainty. "There will be someone else, but it will not be Harry or a copy of Harry," he said. "We will find a solution when it comes to it but maybe not me. It might be another 10 years." For now, the succession question belongs to the future—and to whoever sits in the manager's chair when Kane finally steps away.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
I like him as a nine. He is a natural goalscorer and he has the hunger to be on the scoreboard.— Thomas Tuchel, on Jude Bellingham
The person who is going to replace Kane has already emerged—and that's Jude Bellingham.— Ian Dennis, BBC Radio 5 Live senior football reporter
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei BBC News ↗
General News