At Croke Park's Hogan Stand, a vision of frictionless stadium commerce met the unforgiving test of a packed All-Ireland Hurling Final crowd — and stumbled. The venue's AI-powered Brisk bar system, which uses facial recognition and card scanning to charge customers automatically for drinks, overcharged multiple patrons by as much as three times the correct amount. Internal communications later revealed the problem was broader than the stadium initially acknowledged, touching something older than technology: the distance between a promising idea and a trustworthy one.
Croke Park vows to fix AI bar overcharging after refunding affected fans
Multiple customers were financially overcharged, with some paying up to three times the correct amount for drinks before refunds were processed.
If they're going to use that system, make sure it works first
Mark
So the system was supposed to make things faster. What actually happened?
Mimi
It did make things faster—but it also made them more expensive, at least for some people. The technology worked in the sense that it processed transactions instantly. The problem was in the calculation. People were being charged two or three times what they should have been.
Mark
How many people are we talking about?
Mimi
That's the question nobody can quite answer. Two people called the radio station. But internal emails from the company running the bar mentioned "numerous" overcharges across two weekends. That suggests it was more than a handful of isolated mistakes.
Mark
And they've fixed it now?
Mimi
They say they have. They've refunded everyone, reassessed the system, made changes. But they're making that claim before the biggest crowd of the season shows up. It's a test they can't fail twice.
Mark
Why does facial recognition matter here? Couldn't they just use the card scan?
Mimi
That's a good question. The facial recognition is supposed to track which customer takes which drink. But if the system is already miscalculating charges, adding another layer of tracking doesn't necessarily fix the core problem—it might just make it harder to catch.
Mark
What does this say about AI in public spaces?
Mimi
It says that technology that works in controlled conditions—a concert, a smaller crowd—can break in ways you don't predict when you scale it up. And it says that when it breaks, real people pay real money before anyone notices.
Il Polso
- Customers were silently charged sums like €37.40 for three pints and €60.30 for four drinks — errors that only surfaced when people checked their banking apps in real time.
- Internal Kappture emails, accidentally shared with an affected customer, revealed 'numerous overcharges' across two weekends, suggesting the problem ran deeper than two isolated complaints on national radio.
- A note of institutional anxiety ran through those emails — staff worried that if the overcharging reached the media, it would not be 'a great advertisement' for the system.
- Croke Park's hospitality chief moved to contain the fallout: all affected customers have been refunded and system changes implemented ahead of the All-Ireland Football Final.
- The episode leaves an open question hanging over this weekend's full final crowd — whether the fixes will hold where the original system failed.
At Croke Park's Hogan Stand, a vision of frictionless stadium commerce met the unforgiving test of a packed All-Ireland Hurling Final crowd — and stumbled. The venue's AI-powered Brisk bar system, which uses facial recognition and card scanning to charge customers automatically for drinks, overcharged multiple patrons by as much as three times the correct amount. Internal communications later revealed the problem was broader than the stadium initially acknowledged, touching something older than technology: the distance between a promising idea and a trustworthy one.
The Crossbar Bar in Croke Park's Section 330 was designed to eliminate the oldest frustration in stadium life: the queue. The Brisk system scans your bank card at the entrance, tracks which pre-poured drinks you take using facial recognition, and charges you automatically. No cash, no waiting. A concert season trial had gone smoothly. Then the All-Ireland Hurling Final arrived.
A customer named Kevin ordered three pints and found €37.40 taken from his account — nearly €12.50 per pint. Another customer's friend watched her Revolut app register a €7 charge, then a further €60.30 for four drinks. Both contacted Croke Park and Kappture, the system's operator. Kevin went further: internal Kappture emails accidentally sent to him told a wider story, referencing 'numerous overcharges' across two weekends and an internal push to resolve each case 'as a matter of urgency.' One line acknowledged the reputational risk if the story reached the press.
The GAA's General Manager of Hospitality confirmed that all overcharged customers had been refunded and that the system had been reviewed and adjusted ahead of the Football Final. The Brisk concept, he maintained, was always intended to improve the matchday experience. But as Kevin put it plainly on RTE Radio 1's Liveline: if you deploy a system like this on thousands of people, it has to actually work. The refunds are done. The fixes are in place. Whether they hold under the weight of a full All-Ireland final crowd is the question that remains.
The bar at Croke Park's Hogan Stand was supposed to be the future of stadium service—no queues, no fumbling for cash, just tap your card and walk away with your drink. Instead, it became a cautionary tale about the gap between technological promise and operational reality.
The system, called Brisk, works like this: you scan your bank card at the entrance to the Crossbar Bar in Section 330. Facial recognition and card tracking then monitor which pre-poured drinks you take. The linked card gets charged automatically. It's frictionless, the stadium promised. It's efficient. It reduces lines. Last year's concert season proved the concept worked. But when the All-Ireland Hurling Final brought real crowds through the turnstiles last week, something went badly wrong.
A man named Kevin ordered three pints of Guinness and Rockshore. His card was hit for €37.40—nearly €12.50 per pint. He knew immediately something was off. He checked his banking app, then called Croke Park and Kappture, the company operating the system. Another customer, Niamh, watched her friend's Revolut app light up twice: first a €7 charge, then €60.30 more for four drinks. The math didn't work. A pint at Croke Park doesn't cost fifteen euros.
Kevin went further. He obtained internal emails from Kappture that were accidentally shared with him. They told a larger story than two angry customers on RTE Radio 1's Liveline programme. The emails, sent between colleagues at the bar operator, referenced "numerous overcharges" from Brisk across two weekends. Someone urged the team to "get to the bottom of each case, please, as a matter of urgency." Another line carried a note of anxiety: "if these things start getting out in the media, it's not a great advertisement."
David Adams, the General Manager of Hospitality at GAA headquarters, moved quickly to contain the damage. All overcharged customers have been refunded, he said. The system has been reassessed. Changes have been made. Croke Park is confident the problems won't happen again at this weekend's All-Ireland Football Final. The Brisk concept, Adams emphasized, was always meant to improve the experience—faster service, shorter queues, a better day at the stadium. The trial run during the concert season had worked smoothly.
But the gap between a successful trial and a packed stadium on match day is vast. Kevin's point, made to RTE, cut to the heart of it: if Croke Park and its third-party provider are going to deploy a system like this, they need to make sure it actually works before they turn it loose on thousands of people. The refunds have been issued. The fixes have been made. Whether they'll hold under the pressure of a full All-Ireland final crowd remains to be seen.
Citazioni salienti
Some customers who used the system were overcharged. On review they have all been refunded. The issues raised triggered a reassessment of the process, and we have made some changes to the operation which, we feel, will address these issues.— David Adams, General Manager of Hospitality at Croke Park
If Croke Park and that third-party provider are to use that system, they should make sure it's working properly before they deploy it.— Kevin, affected customer
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su Dublin Live ↗
Technology